The Rise of the Citizen Electrician
The Rise of the Citizen Electrician
George Doubinski, coined the concept of the Citizen Electrician, and I give him full credit for it.
The concept of "citizen developers" has revolutionized low-code app development, enabling non-technical users to create functional applications using platforms like Microsoft's Power Platform. While this democratization of software development has advantages, it's essential to recognize the limitations and potential risks of over-relying on this approach. To illustrate this, let's consider the hypothetical scenario of " citizen electricians" and why we would never apply the same weight to citizen developers.
Citizen Developers: A Mixed Blessing
Citizen developers leverage low-code platforms to build applications, automate workflows, and analyze data without needing deep coding knowledge. This movement has been praised for its benefits:
1. Speed: Solutions can be developed quickly, bypassing traditional IT bottlenecks.
2. Cost-Effective: Reduces the need to hire specialized developers for every small application.
3. User-Centric: Solutions are often more aligned with end-users actual needs as the users develop them.
4. Empowerment: Encourages innovation and problem-solving at all levels of the organization.
However, the reliance on citizen developers can also lead to several issues:
- Quality Control: Without a strong foundation in coding and software development principles, the quality of applications can vary widely.
- Security Risks: Inadequately developed applications may pose security vulnerabilities.
- Maintenance Challenges: Applications developed by citizen developers might need more proper documentation and scalability, making maintenance difficult.
The Hypothetical Citizen Electrician
Imagine if we applied the same concept to electrical work, encouraging everyday employees to take on the role of electricians using simplified tools and guides. Here's why we wouldn't:
1. Safety: Electrical work is inherently dangerous. Improper wiring or installations can lead to fires, electrocution, and other severe hazards. Professional electricians undergo rigorous training and certification to ensure their work meets safety standards.
2. Regulation: The electrical industry is heavily regulated to protect public safety. Strict codes and standards must be adhered to.
3. Complexity: Electrical systems require a deep understanding of physics, circuitry, and materials.
4. Reliability: The integrity of an electrical system is crucial for the functioning of buildings and infrastructure. Electrical work errors can lead to costly repairs, downtime, and even loss of life.
Why the Same Caution Should Apply to Citizen Developers.
While the stakes might not be as immediately dangerous as electrical work, software development also carries significant risks when not handled by professionals:
- Business Impact: Poorly developed applications can disrupt business processes, leading to financial losses and operational inefficiencies.
- Data Security: Inadequate security measures can expose sensitive data to breaches, resulting in legal and reputational damage.
- Long-Term Viability: Applications created without scalability in mind can become unmanageable as business needs grow, leading to costly rewrites or replacements.
Final Thoughts
The hypothetical scenario of citizen electricians highlights the importance of professional expertise in fields where errors can have severe consequences. While the citizen developer model has merits, balancing empowerment with caution is crucial. Just as we would refrain from entrusting critical electrical work to untrained individuals, we should be mindful of the limitations and potential risks of over-relying on citizen developers.
Get in touch to find out how I can help.
